Revealing what separates the hydraulic and electric lifts
Here we'll dive deep into the hydraulic versus electric lift debate. From speed and space considerations to installation and maintenance costs, we'll cover all the important comparative aspects.
What is a hydraulic lift?
A hydraulic lift, such as the OLYMPUS, is a type of lift that operates by using non-compressible oil to propel a piston within a cylinder. When the lift is summoned, a pump pressurises the oil, and the piston elevates the car to the desired floor. During descent, the pressure is released, gradually retracting the piston and lowering the car. This simple technology typically makes it an affordable and cost-effective choice for many operations using heavy machinery.
Hydraulic lifts are typically installed beneath the elevator car, in order to conserve vertical space. However, in certain scenarios, more space might be needed for additional components like pumps and reservoirs.
What is an electric lift?
Electric lifts, as the name suggests, utilise electric motors to steer and lift the elevator car. The most common type of electric lift is the traction elevator. In a traction elevator, an electric motor with a toothed pulley attached to the output shaft drives a cable that runs up and over the pulley. This then connects to the elevator car and a counterweight. When called, the motor turns the pulley, raising or lowering the car. The counterweight reduces strain on the motor and eliminates the need for complex gearboxes. Electric lifts are known for their speed, smooth operation, and versatility in accommodating various floor heights. Despite typically requiring more upfront investment, they offer long-term energy efficiency and relatively low maintenance costs.
What are the advantages of hydraulic lifts?
Choosing hydraulic lifts over electric lifts can offer some distinct advantages for businesses and landowners. Some of these benefits of hydraulic lifts include:
- Affordability
Hydraulic lifts are often more budget-friendly upfront, making them an attractive option for those looking for cost-effective solutions. - Space efficiency
Due to their cylinder shape and the placement of components beneath the elevator car, hydraulic lifts require less vertical space. This makes them more suitable for installations with limited overhead clearance. - Heavy load handling
Hydraulic lifts generally have a capability to handle heavier loads compared to electric lifts. This makes them particularly suitable for applications where lifting heavier items or accommodating larger capacities is a priority.
What are the advantages of electric lifts?
On the other hand, there are some aspects to electric lifts that may prove beneficial over hydraulic lifts. Some of the key advantages of electric lifts include:
- Speed and smooth operation
Electric lifts offer faster and smoother rides compared to hydraulic lifts, providing passengers with enhanced comfort and efficiency. - Versatility
With the ability to accommodate various floor heights, electric lifts are suitable for a wide range of buildings and installations - Energy efficiency
Electric lifts typically require less power to operate. This means that they may incur lower maintenance costs over their lifespan compared to hydraulic lifts.
What is the difference between hydraulic lifts and electric lifts?
Generally, the main differences between hydraulic and electric lifts concern their speed, space requirements and affordability. There are also distinctions in potential maintenance costs and demands. On one hand, hydraulic lifts offer slower speeds but require less space, making them suitable for cost-effective installations with limited overhead clearance. They typically have simpler and more affordable installation processes.
However, their backup options during power outages are limited, relying primarily on safety measures like counterweights.
In contrast, electric lifts provide faster operation, versatility, and potentially lower maintenance costs. However, they generally require higher upfront costs. Additionally, electric lifts offer the advantage of battery backup systems for continued use during power outages, which is not possible with hydraulic lifts.
Hydraulic Lift | Electric Lift | |
Speed | Slower | Faster |
Space Requirement | More space needed for additional components | Generally more space efficient |
Installation | Simpler and more affordable | Higher upfront cost |
Maintenance | Lower amount of maintenance | Lower maintenance costs |
Backup System | Limited options during power outages | Battery backup available for continued use |
Explore the space-saving TRAFFICO hydraulic lift
The TRAFFICO hydraulic car lift is a space-saving hydraulic lift designed for flexibility and speed. Forming part of Lodige Industries’ innovative range of lift solutions, the TRAFFICO is perfect for urban areas with limited parking space. TRAFFICO ensures efficient parking with its fast operation and user-friendly controls. And, equipped with an array of safety features, it guarantees a secure experience for drivers and passengers alike.
Or, if you’re looking for an alternative to hydraulic lifts, take a look at the SHERPA goods-only lift, tailor-made for warehouse environments. With pitless installation and quick setup, SHERPA allows for efficient goods transportation without the need for extensive modifications to existing structures.
